Glass: The Award For Change > Glass: The Award for Change

CORRECT THE INTERNET

DDB NEW ZEALAND, Auckland / TEAM HEROINE / 2024

Awards:

Gold Spikes Asia
CampaignCampaign(opens in a new tab)
Case Film
Supporting Images
Supporting Images

Overview

Credits

Overview

Why is this work relevant for Glass: The Award for Change?

This campaign is dedicated to highlighting and correcting a bias that makes sportswomen’s achievements invisible in the place we all go to find them: the internet.

Many of the world's greatest athletes are women. And many of the world’s biggest sporting records are held by women. But when asked simple, non-gendered questions to find this information, like ‘who has scored the most goals in international football?’, search engines incorrectly favour more popular, more recognised sportsmen, ignoring women’s achievements.

Algorithms have learned to tell us that Cristiano Ronaldo’s 119 international goals are superior to female footballer Christine Sinclair’s 190 international goals, because that's what they think people want to see. And that's why many so many of the best sportsmen are household names, while the greatest sportswomen have little name recognition at all.

Our mission is to correct this bias, and make sportswomen more visible to all who search for them.

Background

The internet has a bias.

Search algorithms are trained on human behaviour, designed to give us what they think we’re looking for. Now, they’ve learnt our bias towards men.

Asked simple, non-gendered questions, like “who has scored the most goals in international football?”, search engines prioritise the more recognised male athletes, even when facts say it’s a female athlete - making women and their achievements invisible.

So Team Heroine, a women’s sport marketing agency that seeks to connect female athletes with brands to ensure they're better recognized in a world where women’s sport receives just 0.4% of media coverage and 4% of total sponsorship, aimed to correct the internet's bias.

Our objective was to highlight the incorrect searches and get as many people as possible report these inaccuracies to the search engines so they could be corrected, and the achievements of sportswomen would become visible for all to see.

Describe the cultural / social / political climate around gender representation and the significance of the work within this context

This is a bias that affects half the population.

It affects everyone who searches the internet.

It affects the world’s biggest sports, athletes and teams.

And it affects the next generation of little girls looking to find and follow in the footsteps of inspiring sportswomen.

Currently, this bias is making women’s sport invisible - receiving just 0.4% of media coverage and 4% of total sponsorship globally. Many male athletes are household names, while most female athletes have very little name recognition at all - made worse by the fact that many of these sportswomen’s achievements are statistically superior to the men.

On top of this, search engines have known about this bias internally for over a decade. Many teams have been put together to address it. But internal politics see monetised opportunities often taking priority, and the teams who have experimented with solutions have struggled to secure resources to see them implemented.

This campaign sets out to see them finally implemented. To make the search engines recognize and prioritize this problem. To correct the misinformation, correct the bias, make the achievements of sportswomen visible, and to see them finally given the recognition they deserve.

Describe the creative idea.

We created an initiative that used the power of the people who use the internet, to right the wrongs of it. Our mission: Correct The Internet and make the achievements of sportswomen visible.

The only way to correct search engines is by people sending feedback when they find something wrong. So we developed a tool that highlighted the incorrect searches that create the bias, and allowed people to report them with just a couple of clicks. New incorrect searches were revealed each day, showing the world the problem and inspiring them to take action.

To ensure search engines didn’t dismiss our feedback as bots, we created hundreds of unique report messages to be sent from different user IP addresses around the world. Our simplified way of giving feedback made it quick and easy to report feedback on a scale the search engines couldn’t ignore, making them to take action too.

Describe the strategy

Internally, this problem has been on search engine radars for years, with many teams experimenting solutions.

Monetised opportunities often take priority, so these teams struggle securing resources to implement solutions.

To make them prioritise this problem, we focussed on:

-External pressure (PR/awareness) on marketing/business, targeting the ‘trust’ pillar of brand health tracking which we know is monitored.

-Internal engineering pressure via bug reports from millions of users, to prioritise our corrections.

We conducted an audit of simple, non-gendered searches across Google, Bing, Yahoo & Baidu, collecting search results that used incorrect statistical data to create bias. We quickly discovered 50+ incorrect searches and added them to our tool for people to report.

With 50+ inaccuracies that affected different countries, sports, teams, and athletes, we revealed new stats each day until we saw change, each targeting a new audience, creating enough internal and external pressure for the search engines to act.

Describe the execution

To get the attention of the search engines, we needed people power to deliver the feedback highlighting each inaccuracy to each search engine.

We launched with a film that showed the reality of what happens when a little girl asks the internet a question and receives an answer that incorrectly puts a sportsman ahead of a sportswoman. This film quickly spread around the world, inspiring people to act.

This led them to the online tool we developed to highlight the incorrect searches and allowed people to report them as direct feedback messages with just a couple of clicks.

New incorrect search results were revealed each day across social, digital, and OOH, and shared globally. Each targeted a new audience, building us a following of athletes, sports teams, advocacy groups, media and the public, which led to more and more reports being made and saw search engines take action.

Describe the results / impact

Our campaign reached over 1 billion people globally.

Had 120+ pieces of media coverage, including BBC, NBC, Fox News, Sky Sport & Forbes.

Millions of people reported to search engines through our tool, social channels, and the media.

And we’re now supported by over 50 global brands, including the United Nations.

When we started, the search results never showed sportswomen.

Although people can be served different results based on location, demographic and search history, we are now beginning to see change to many of the searches, correctly recognizing a female.

Now, a problem that has existed within search engines for decades has new momentum and is being solved, with Google deploying new features to highlight women’s sport, offering both male and female results on searches.

And now, Correct The Internet is part of UK/international government enquiries into misinformation, to help change the future of the internet.

More Entries from DDB NEW ZEALAND

24 items

Gold Cannes Lions
SAMSUNG ITEST

Consumer Goods

SAMSUNG ITEST

SAMSUNG, DDB NEW ZEALAND

(opens in a new tab)